top of page
  • Writer's pictureDevon Noel Lee

Family History Writing Mistake to Avoid: Telling Only Happy Family Stories

Are you tempted to portray your ancestors as glamorous, heroic, or flawless when sharing your family history? Do you shy away from stories that reveal their vulnerabilities, struggles, or flaws?

In this insightful interview, we explore the common mistake of only telling happy stories and the importance of authenticity in writing family history.

In a fascinating conversation with Laura Hedgecock, author of "Memories of Me: A Complete Guide to Telling and Sharing the Stories of Your Life," we delve into the value of embracing the full spectrum of human experiences in our narratives.

The Pitfall of Only Telling Happy Stories

Laura cautions against presenting sugar-coated stories that lack authenticity. She explains that such stories that fall into the "sugar won't melt in my mouth" category. Often used in the South, this expression symbolizes the artificial sweetness that pervades narratives focused solely on positive aspects.

By contrast, the opposite of happy stories isn't necessarily sad stories; it is the real stories. Real stories reflect the truth of our ancestors' lives, showcasing their humanity in all its complexity.

The Importance of Authenticity in Writing Family History

Authenticity is critical in crafting engaging family history narratives. By sharing joys, sorrows, triumphs, and struggles, we create connections that resonate with readers. When we omit the storms that preceded the happy moments, the perfection portrayed fails to evoke an emotional response.

In the article, Laura shares her personal journey and her grandmother's writing as examples. She highlights the importance of sharing authentic stories, even when they are difficult or uncomfortable. Something her grandmother neglected to do.

↪️ Do you want to write a family history book?

Grab your copy of this FREE Writing Guide:

laptop and writing notes with title Free Guide: 5 Steps to Quickly Write Family Histories

Creating Connections Through Authentic Narratives

Laura suggests that the best family historians offer readers a slice of life. Such stories allow readers to imagine knowing someone they never had the chance to meet or getting to know them in a new light.

By weaving together different facets of an ancestor's life, we gain a deeper understanding of who they were as individuals.

Start Writing and Sharing Your Story

Laura advises starting by writing these stories for yourself, giving yourself the freedom to express raw emotions and memories. Once you have the initial draft, you can assess your motives and decide if and how to share them with others.

Timing and the right audience are crucial considerations when sharing less-than-happy stories. Writing partners or critique groups can offer valuable feedback and provide a safe space for exploring these narratives.

Additionally, reaching out to a broader community, whether through blogging or memoir classes, can be empowering. Sharing your story with strangers who can offer support and understanding can help you navigate the process and release any shame or burden associated with difficult experiences.

Capturing Real Lives, Avoids Family History Writing Mistakes

Ultimately, writing family history is about more than just preserving names and dates. It is about capturing the essence of our ancestors' lives and creating connections with future generations.

By embracing the full range of human experiences and sharing the highs and the lows, we create a rich history that profoundly resonates with readers.

Start Writing an Authentic Family History Today

Writing a family history is a journey that requires honesty, vulnerability, and authenticity. Avoid the trap of only telling happy stories and instead embrace the power of sharing authentic, unfiltered narratives. By doing so, you breathe life into your ancestors' stories and provide future generations with a profound understanding of their roots.

Listen to the Full Interview with Laura Hedgecock

Watch the video Don't Only Tell Happy Family Stories - AVOID This Writing Mistake on the Write Your Family History Channel to gain further insights from Laura Hedgecock on the importance of authenticity in writing family history.

Discover how embracing the full spectrum of human experiences can enhance your storytelling and create connections that will resonate with your readers. Start crafting your family history narrative today and inspire others to do the same.

Continue Learning How to Write Family Histories

Note: To leave a comment, you will be asked to sign in with your Facebook or Google Account. This action will help reduce spam comments on our site. I hope you'll understand.

bottom of page