Turning Unidentified Family Photos into Memories via Quick Photo Books
- Devon Noel Lee
- 21 hours ago
- 3 min read
Do you have a stack of photos featuring unidentified ancestors? You know they’re important, but you just can’t place the names or stories behind the faces. It’s frustrating, right?
Relatives might hold the answers, but asking them isn't always straightforward—especially if they aren’t tech-savvy or active on social media. So, how can you bridge the gap and bring those mystery photos back to life?

Why Technology Alone May Not Be the Answer
Sure, Facebook groups or text messages can sometimes solve the mystery, but not everyone has access—or the patience—to sift through endless photo posts. And if they do respond, their comments might get lost in the chaos of other replies. Sound familiar? It’s a common roadblock for genealogists.
What if there were a simpler, more personal way to gather these answers while creating a keepsake your family will treasure?
The Perfect Solution: Mystery Photo Books
Here’s a simple yet powerful idea: create printed photo books with space for your relatives to write their insights directly onto the pages. Not only does this make it easier to gather memories and identifications, but you’ll also have the added benefit of preserving their handwriting—a priceless family artifact in itself!
Let’s walk through how to make one of these books step by step.
7 Steps to Create a Family Photo Mystery Book
1. Organize Your Mystery Photos
Start by creating a folder on Google Drive, Dropbox, or your computer titled "Unidentified Family Members." Gather a minimum of 15-20 photos for the project. The more, the better (even if that sounds wrong).
2. Choose a Photo Book Service
While Chatbooks is a popular option, consider other services like Shutterfly, Snapfish, or Mixbook, which also allow for creative customizations and are beginner-friendly. Look for services that:
Allow single-photo-per-page layouts.
Offer space around the images for writing.
Print affordable, high-quality books quickly.
3. Customize Your Book Layout
Cover Design: Give your book a title like “Mystery Faces: Help Us Identify Our Ancestors.”
Photo Pages: Use layouts with 1-2 photos per page. Leave plenty of white space around each image.
Captions: Include any small details you do know, such as “Photo taken in Ohio, 1930s” or leave a prompt like, “Who are these people?”
Add Writing Prompts: Insert blank text pages with questions like:
"Who do you recognize in these photos?"
"When do you think this photo was taken?"
"What stories or memories does this photo bring to mind?"
↪️ Do you want to write a family history book?
Grab your copy of this FREE Writing Guide.
4. Review and Refine
Remove any low-resolution images that might print poorly. Preview the book carefully to ensure everything looks clean and easy to read.
5. Order Physical Copies
Print several copies of the new family memories book to share with family members at reunions or send by mail. Services like Shutterfly often have discounts for bulk orders.
6. Engage Your Relatives
Share your mystery book at family gatherings or mail it to key relatives who might know the answers. Encourage them to:
Write directly on the pages.
Pass the book to others who might have clues.
7. Follow Up and Reward Knowledge
When relatives contribute valuable information, thank them! Whether it’s a heartfelt letter or a small keepsake like a framed photo of their handwriting, showing gratitude can go a long way.

Making the Past Personal Again With This Family Memories Book
Unidentified photos don’t have to stay mysteries forever. With a bit of creativity and a personal touch, you can involve your family in preserving these stories while creating a meaningful keepsake.
Have you ever used a similar method for identifying old family photos? Let me know in the comments—I’d love to hear your tips and tricks!