How many small DNA segments are legitimate?
If you’ve looked at Family Tree DNA data, then you’ve seen that some of your matches have some small segments that are less than seven centimorgans. Ever wonder how many of these small segments could actually be matches?
The Small DNA Segment Debate
There’s some debate on them. Some people see them, and they think that well we can use these to help find others. However, much of the research on small segments shows that most small segments are not real. They are DNA that could have been passed down from 10 or 20 or 30 generations ago.
From a genetic genealogy standpoint, you will not be able to show from in the family tree or with other records. In other words, it’s not really good as a piece of evidence.
There are also many small segments, particularly the smaller they get, that are just common amongst big populations, particularly in endogamous populations. You don’t have to have endogenous ancestors to have small segments that are nearly ubiquitous in that population.
When looking at Family Tree DNA data, we’ll look at the segments. How many of those small segments should we be able to trust as maybe even being actual matches?
Analyzing Small Segment DNA for Reliability
To begin with, I have both of one set of my grandparents tested. In doing that, I know exactly which of these large segments of DNA that I have are shared between that grandparent and me.
Because of the way recombination works, these will only be great big segments, particularly because it was through my father. This means there’s even less recombination so that I will have great big large segments. I don’t see any small segments.
In fact, in my DNA that I share with my grandmother, there’s only one less than 40 centimorgans segment. It's 36 centimorgans. There’s nothing in the range of five, six, ten, or even 20 centimorgans.
This is perfect for looking at small segments. Why the first thing I need is a grandparent that I match with that, I have that data so then I can define what segments I know for sure are from that grandparent.
The second thing I need is some other relatives, such as first, second, third, or fourth cousins, who have a common ancestor with that grandparent somehow.
Then I can look at the segment data from each one of those matches and overlap it on my grandmother’s data. If those small segments are outside of those big segments, then they couldn’t have been inherited through that ancestor. If they are within it, then they could be, but it’s not definite.
Watch this video.
Analyzing the Small Segments of DNA of a First Cousin Twice Removed
This first set of data is from a first cousin twice removed. I can mark all of the shared segments that are bigger than seven centimorgans, and they also fall within where I share DNA with my grandmother. All of the other segments are segments that are smaller than seven centimorgans. You can color-code these small segments. Red if they fall outside of what you share with the common ancestor and yellow if they are small, but you and this match share the segments with your common ancestor.
In this example, I share 14 segments with the first cousin twice removed, but four of them are impossible segments. My match and I couldn’t have inherited these segments through my grandmother because I don’t share them with my grandma.
In short, 28% of the segments I share with this first cousin twice removed does not point to a common ancestor.
Analyzing the Small Segments of DNA of a Second Cousin Once Removed
With a second cousin once removed, I share 104 centimorgans with them. When I take out the small segments (less than 7 shared centimorgans), it’s only 74 centimorgans. This amount falls within the range of where you would expect a second cousin once-removed to be you.
We share 11 total segments that are small segments, with three being impossible segments. Of the amount of shared DNA, 27% would be from the common ancestor. Compare that to the first cousin twice removed, and you’ll see they are relatively the same.
If I stopped comparing matches here, you might think that about a quarter of these segments are impossible segments (segments not from the same common ancestor).
Analyzing the Small Segments of DNA of a Fourth Cousin Once Removed
I have a fourth cousin-once-removed, which represents a distant relative. According to Family Tree DNA, overall, I share 49 centimorgans with them. When I remove all those small segments, I only share 28 centimorgans with this individual. Those centimorgans only appear in one segment.
I share nine additional segments of DNA with them, but they are all small segments. Four of those nine segments are impossible segments, which means I don’t share DNA in those areas with my grandmother, so I couldn’t have inherited that DNA from the same person.
I should point out that I have constructed extensive family trees for me and this match, and there isn’t a second path of relationship between us.
In short, 44% of the small segments of fourth cousins once removed are impossible segments.
Analyzing the Small Segments of DNA of a Fifth Cousin
For my fifth cousin match on FamilyTree DNA, I share 52 centimorgans initially, but once you remove all those small segments, it’s only 11 centimorgans. Other researchers would define many of these 11 cMs as small segments.
I share 17 small segments with this person, and 9 of them are impossible segments.
Thus, just over 52% of all the segments are impossible segments.
↪️ Confused about DNA and genealogy?
Grab your copy of this FREE DNA guide:
How Useful are Small DNA Segments
This analysis helps me to draw a couple of conclusions.
The number of small segments doesn’t appear to line up with how distantly related you are. The number of small segments is really random.
The percentage of impossible segments appears to be going up the more distantly related you are. You share less and less DNA the more distantly related you are, and so you’d think that more of these small segments might end up being impossible segments.
There might be many different things that people can do with small segments, but if all you share with a match is a small segment, they’re not going to be very useful for you.
Should You Research Small DNA Segments?
If you’re beginning in genetic genealogy, then completely ignore the small segments. For an experienced genealogist, you may want to start tackling some of these small segments to see whether they are real matches.
If you never get to researching your small segments in your genetic genealogy research, then you’re probably gonna do fine because there’s plenty of matches out there that share these big segments with you that you can find matches for, and you can find relationships.